Goffman's statement suggests that 'the story in the book wasn't true,' Lubet said in an interview, adding, 'One has to wonder what else she embellished.' In a follow-up article posted by The New Republic, he pointed to what he called 'serious discrepancies' between her two accounts, including her descriptions of her mental state. She added, 'I went because I knew these drives were about expressing anger and about grieving, not about doing actual violence.' When she got into the car, 'I had good reason to believe that this night would not end in violence or injury,' Goffman said in the statement.

But Tuesday, she posted a statement on her faculty Web page at the University of Wisconsin, where she is an assistant professor, elaborating on what she called the 'summary account' of the incident given in her book. Goffman, 33, declined to be interviewed about Lubet's claims. According to legal experts he consulted, Goffman's actions, as described in the book, 'constituted conspiracy to commit murder under Pennsylvania law.'ĭavid Rudovsky, a lawyer representing Goffman, said Friday that he was unaware of any legal investigation of the matter, and Goffman's publishers, the University of Chicago Press and Picador, say they stand behind her and her book.

No matter that nothing happened, Lubet writes. The man turns out not to be the killer, and no shots are fired, but Goffman describes being deeply shaken by the recognition of what she calls 'my desire for vengeance.' In Goffman's account, Mike, with a gun tucked into his pants, gets out of the car to approach someone. In that anecdote, Goffman describes driving the car when a young man named Mike went looking for the man who had recently killed their close friend Chuck. Lubet's charge, made in an article in the online book review The New Rambler and reposted in condensed form by The New Republic, concerns an anecdote that appears at the end of a long appendix in which Goffman describes how she spent six years observing and sometimes living among a group of young men in a Philadelphia neighbourhood she calls Sixth Street.

Alice goffman on the run summary